Monday, September 5, 2011

Marbled Peanut Butter & Chocolate Snickers Cookies.

Important things first. 

It's September. 

I can officially bake with pumpkin pie spice and candy corn now. No? Yes.
But what? How did this happen. I promise you, it was just June. And if we're going there, it was maybe even still technically spring. I was daydreaming of red, white, and blue things to bake and lazy afternoons laying on the beach and grilling pizzas, picnics and hiking and summer fairs, concerts and funnel cakes, ice cold drinks in frosty Mason jars, new flip-flops, fireworks, barbeques, peanut butter s'mores, and camping.

Oh P.S. And an entire season of TrueBlood.    

Now there's only one episode of TrueBlood left (one! ONE.), my s'more count is at zero, and it's September
Dislike.

But the one thing I did do this summer, in droves, and the one thing that always makes me feel a bit more like myself, even when it's September and I haven't been camping or felt the sand between my toes or had a s'more in my face or landed a career or come anywhere close to having that perfect body that fits into a bikini, (let alone a one-piece. P.S. Just that word "bikini" makes me want to punch something.)... is baking. Because it's my thing.

And it probably explains the whole swimsuit situation.

But I think I do it pretty well. And for five minutes, or, you know... forty-five minutes to an hour, it makes me feel confident and purposeful and in control of my life and, honestly, a little bit sassy.  
I'm bolding that. Cuz that's what you do with important things. And because real life? Five minutes after I post this I'll probably sink back down into this quicksand of a funk I've been stuck in the whole summer, where I don't feel confident or purposeful or in control or sassy.

But instead... I'll tell you about these cookies. And then maybe I'll check out of life for 72 hours and finish reading The Help
Sugary-rich peanut butter chocolate chip cookies + double chocolate chip cookies with chunks of chewy, bubbly, caramel-y, nougat-y Snickers bars and bits of almonds. That's what's happening here.
These marbled cookies started out the way most of my cookies do: my boyfriend demanded wanted them. Not feeling all that inspired that day, I asked him what kind he wanted and got this real specific answer:

"I don't know. Cookies, you know? Something chocolate-y. Or something peanut butter-y. Oooh, maybe something chocolate-y almond-y?" 
So I made two batches of cookies and swirled them together! And threw in some in Almond Snickers, since they're his favorite (and hopefully counted as something "chocolate-y almond-y"). 

My favorite part is the gooey pockets of caramel that bubbled up out of these cookies.
I think they would taste even better with chopped up bits of peanut butter Snickers bars... or even Reese's peanut butter cups. Peanut butter = <3.

P.S. If I had my way, the surface of the moon would look like this. 
But then I'd become an astronaut and, you know... eat the moon.

No biggie.

Marbled Peanut Butter & Chocolate Snickers Cookies


Peanut Butter Dough
2 cups creamy peanut butter
2 cups granulated sugar
2 eggs
1 cup chocolate chips

Chocolate Dough
1 cup (2 sticks) butter, at room temperature
1 cup granulated sugar
3/4 cup brown sugar
2 eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 3/4 cup all-purpose flour
1 1/4 cup cocoa powder
2 teaspoons baking soda
1/4 teaspoon salt
4 regular-sized Snicker bars, chopped into small pieces
3/4 cup chocolate chips

Preheat oven to 350°F. 

For the peanut butter dough, cream together the butter, sugar, and egg until dough forms. Stir in chocolate chips. 

For the chocolate dough, cream together the butter, sugar, and brown sugar until well combined. Slowly beat in egg and vanilla until well combined. In a separate bowl, mix together the flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and salt. Slowly add the butter mixture until well combined. Stir in chopped Snickers pieces and chocolate chips. 

Take a tablespoon of peanut butter dough and a tablespoon of chocolate dough and press together. Gently roll into a ball and place on a lightly greased baking sheet. 

Bake for 9-11 minutes, or until done. Let cool 5 minutes on baking sheet before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely.

Makes about 5 dozen cookies

Source: Adapted from Picky Palate.

Comments (38)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Oh I am so super excited to try this!
Those. Look. FABULOUS. =D
Those look DELICIOUS! now if only I werent on my "die-t" lol. ah! maybe just maybe I will dive into those and make them! thankks for sharing they look beautiful!
woah! those cookies lookout of this world good! bookmarking!
I love your important bolded comment! I feel the same way about baking, it is totally my thing... but please don't feel unimportant when you are through with baking because I know you have an awesome purpose and are loved by lots of people, including all of your followers who wouldn't know what to do with themselves if you didn't give us these yummy recipes! :)
1 reply · active 707 weeks ago
Great idea with these!
mmmmm...I want one of those cookies.
Bring on the Fall flavors. Can't wait.
Wow, wow and wow, these look so delish! My boyf would also love these on account of their being peanut butter flavour and snickers! Also True Blood, I can fully appreciate how addictive that show is....! Love it!
What a great idea! These look so good, I know for sure I'll have to try baking these sometime when I have many people around to share them with, otherwise I bet I'd eat the whole lot.
This is a genius recipe! I think it looks like the best cookie flavor combo ever! I will be making these once I'm back up and baking again!
Ooo, these look so yummy! I discovered your blog through foodgawker and I'm glad :)
YUM, YUM, YUM, YUMMY !!! Chocolate +Peanut Butter = Perfect Match
Those Look amazing! Everyone knows chocolate and peanut butter are the world's best combination, and the contrasts of colors here is amazing. I bookmarked it. Can't wait to try...as soon as I get my mixer fixed.

-Miriam
Oh.My.God. These look amazing :O
These look so delicious!! I can't wait to try them out. My husband will love them.

PS - I couldn't agree more about the surface of the moon.
Oh My! I think I gaines 5 lbs just reading this Girl! But have to try this out! thanks for sharing! Love reading The Help too! Check my blog on it! Enjoy!
No flour in the peanut butter dough?
Awesome!!
Oh wow! So glad I stumbled across these cookies. They look incredible!
Sooo excited to make these!!
These look better than they taste. There is something weird about the peanut butter dough with no flour or leavening in it. It gives that part of the cooked a little bit of a weird texture. I made them for a party and although everyone wowed over them I had a lot left over. Maybe a more tender, regular kind of peanut butter cookie dough would work better?
I loved the idea for these cookies, but I found that the peanut butter dough was dry. I had to add extra oil to get it at a malleable stage - maybe coz I used natural peanut butter? I did a few test cookies and they needed the oil. Also, the chocolate dough was sticky and too moist. I had to add ~3 tbs flour to get it to stick to itself. But after the adjustments, absolutely sublime. Thick and moist and chewy and uuuuuuggggh. Thank you, so much.
Agreed about the textures not melding. The chocolate dough is very moist, and the peanut butter dough surprisingly dries a bit quicker, despite not having any flour in it. I'd add a bit more flour to the chocolate dougn, and a little extra oil to the peanut butter (even though I used organic creamy and there was plenty of oil). These are VERY sweet - almost too sweet. Wondering if I might even cut down the sugar next time as well. But they look amazing and do taste incredible.
I made these, exactly as the recipe calls for, and they were AMAZING. Freezed some, post-baking - only lasted three days in the freezer, because we ran out of non-frozen. Once they thawed, yeah... some didn't quite make it to that state, I couldn't wait, they were just as good! Everyone loved them. Making another batch to bring to work for the second time within two weeks.

Kerry, please, oh please, write a book! Between your sense of humor and wonderful recipes, it would be EPIC.
Hi, I am 12 years old and have baked lots of recipes from your site. i first stumbled on this site when I jazzed up a box of vanilla pound cake by making it swirled[with chocolate]. I have made a lot of recipes including chocolate chips, like different variations of chocolate chips cookies and swirled cookies. Right now, peanut butter and chocolate snikers cookies are baking in the oven. It is great to have warm cookies. I look here for some sweet when I decide to bake. Thanks for this site.

Post a new comment

Comments by