Monday, October 3, 2011

White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies.

A few weeks ago I wandered into the kitchen and found these two cookies sitting perfectly displayed on the middle of the counter. They couldn't have been more obvious if they'd been placed on a cookie pedestal with a tiny cookie spotlight.  
Raspberry cheesecake cookies from Subway. Have you tried these? Swoon.

I looked around. "They're for you!" my mom said, leaping into the room.

Suspicious.  

"Really?" 

"Well... kind of. Can you make them? They're like a cookie (<-- actual words). With cheesecake. And berries. Bits of berries. Like jam, but not. Okay, love you!" 

Honestly.
The last time I tried making white chocolate raspberry cookies, they turned into white chocolate raspberry fail. But I like a challenge and recreating recipes (as long as it doesn't involve yeast and patience and letting things rise) and can I tell you?
These are one of the best cookies I have ever made. I know I say that with almost every cookie post, but this time I'm super serious. 
They're soft and chewy, like a sugar cookie, but with all the flavor of a raspberry cheesecake. And they taste exactly like the ones from Subway. Maybe even a little bit better. 
The secret? 
This $.99 box of muffin mix! (It comes in blueberry too. Can you imagine? Blueberry cheesecake cookies. With macadamia nuts! This is dangerous thinking...)
And even though they're made with muffin mix and the dough is super soft and, yeah, they kind of look like fat, fluffy pancakes while they're baking, they really are the same texture as a regular bakery-style cookie. I know... I was suspicious too. I thought they would be cakey and soft and fall apart, but trust.
See? Thick. Chewy. Un-pancake-y. Perfect.
Oh and did I mention they're made with muffin mix? That pretty makes them a legit breakfast.
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake Cookies


2 (7-ounce) boxes Jiffy raspberry muffin mix
4 ounces cream cheese, softened
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter, softened
2 tablespoons butter-flavored shortening 
1/2 cup brown sugar, firmly packed
2 eggs
1 1/2 cups white chocolate chips 

In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat together the cream cheese, butter, shortening, and brown sugar, until just combined (I beat mine until it was completely smooth, but still had little chunks of cream cheese). Add the eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition. 

Add the muffin mix and using a wooden spoon, mix until incorporated. Stir in the white chocolate chips and place in the refrigerator to chill for at least 2 hours. 
Preheat oven to 350°F. Lightly grease baking sheets and roll dough into tablespoon-size balls. Place 2-inches apart on baking sheet and bake for 10-12 minutes, until just turning golden around the edges.

Cool five minutes on baking sheet before removing to wire racks to cool completely.

Source: Barely adapted from Just A Pinch.

Comments (104)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
the muffin mix seems so amazing- what a chewy factor it must have
colleen laquay urbaniuk's avatar

colleen laquay urbaniuk · 703 weeks ago

looks like total breakfast food to me too!!! thanks for sharing...now off to find some muffin mix...
1 reply · active 410 weeks ago
looks like total breakfast food to me too!!! thanks for sharing...now off to find some muffin mix...
MY favorite cookies from Subway!!!!! Those look so good and I'm sad, here in Canada (well at least the part I'm at) we don't have Jiffy anything mix! It sucks because as a California girl, growing up in a "Southern like" home, corn bread was always around. I usually go across the border in Michigan and get a few dozen boxes, I'll have to try and talk the hubby into going with me soon so I can find the raspberry mix! Great recipe as always!!!
3 replies · active 410 weeks ago
oh my!! I need these! I've never had them at subway.... I'll have to get one sometime to try them and then make your recipe. I laugh because growing up that Jiffy mix was what I started out baking... my mom always had boxes of the blueberry and raspberry muffin mixes as well as the corn bread. I think they used to be 3 for a $1
Thank you for posting this! I had Subway's version of this cookie and it was to die for! But I felt a *little* guilty loving them so much because of the preservatives and add-ins and whatnot that tend to be in store bought cookies. I can't wait to try them! And if it goes well, I'm thinking blueberry lemon cheesecake would be another winner!
Those look fantastic....almost make me wanna lick the screen...well not really :)
But I'm super impressed that you re-created them with Jiffy mix....finally a good use for it!
But I will be trying these out....yummers!!!
Oh boy these looks dangerous in a very very good way!
Okay, I just made these and they turned out flat as a pancake! What's up with that? Any suggestions?
6 replies · active 534 weeks ago
Simple! Looks awesome!
These look awesome. I'm going to give them a try as soon as I get some Jiffy Muffin mix.
These sound and look delicious! :)
These look great! I was wondering what the recipe would be if I wanted to make White chocolate raspberry cookies minus the cheesecake? I'm not really good at these things and was wondering what I would add/subtract from the recipe.. please & thanks! :)
Loverly. And your use of muffin mix is genius!
I couldn't find raspberry Jiffy mix so used blueberry. Also, only had regular shortening on hand instead of raspberry. Turned out very yummy! Thx for sharing recipe.
Meant used regular shortening instead if butter flavored. :-) Long day....
1 reply · active 693 weeks ago
Used the Blueberry mix and they are awesome! Dangerously addictive though. :)
1 reply · active 693 weeks ago
Mine came out like flat pancakes. Thin and weak. I refrigerated for 2.5 hours and used shortening. Some came out okay, most were ugly though :(
Mine flattened out and fell apart really easily :( I refridgerated overnight. Maybe if I would have baked them longer, they would have held together better, but I hated to end up burning them. They taste WONDERFUL though! I'll let you know if I play around with them again and get better results!
Made these for the first time tonight and they were great! made them in raspberry and in blueberry.. both great. but had a little more of a muffin taste, understandable with the muffin mix though!
I cannot even begin to tell you how excited I am to make these for Christmas gifts for everyone! Buuut I have a couple questions first. 1. Do you HAVE to use butter flavored shortening? And 2. What if you don't have a paddle attachment for your mixer?
2 replies · active 693 weeks ago
I fucking love you!
2 replies · active 616 weeks ago
I trusted...and they turned out very flat :( they taste amazing though
Anne again's avatar

Anne again · 693 weeks ago

So I tried it with the blueberry muffin mix and I did the exact same thing as I did with the raspberry ones. same time in the fridge and everything and they came out perfect!! Not flat at all! I don't get it...
Dominique L's avatar

Dominique L · 693 weeks ago

I've made these three times in the past week for my sorority bake sale, then because they were just such a hit! I've had EVERYONE asking for the recipe.

Post a new comment

Comments by